Menu of Ligonier Creamery in Ligonier, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Ligonier Creamery, nestled in the heart of Ligonier, PA, is a charming ice cream shop that masterfully blends nostalgia with quality. Located at 105 E Main St, this creamery offers an inviting atmosphere inside a neat old building, adding character to every visit. The vibe here is warm and lively, reflecting a genuine passion for handcrafted desserts.

The menu is a treasure trove of classic and inventive flavors. Standouts include the Banana Split Bar, a nostalgic delight that’s both rich and refreshing. The 5 Chocolates selection caters to true chocolate lovers, providing depth with multiple cocoa notes. One cannot miss the Chocolate Soft Serve topped with hot fudge—creamy, smooth, and decadently layered. For those seeking something unique, the Coffee & Donuts Ice Cream offers a playful twist, melding familiar morning flavors into a sweet treat.

The Red Raspberry Cheesecake and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough flavors showcase the creamery’s skill in balancing richness with freshness. The Butter Pecan Ice Cream Waffle Cone delivers both texture and warmth in every bite, a true comfort food encapsulated in a cone. Lemon Soft Serve with Blueberry Yogurt Swirled presents a zesty, tangy contrast, refreshing and light amid heavier options.

Specialty sundaes such as The Banana Split, Pecan Snapper, and the Ligonier Parfait further elevate the experience, spotlighting thoughtful combinations of textures and flavors. Shakes and beverages, especially the well-loved peanut butter shakes and the Utter Latte, round out the menu, catering to those who want a creamy sip alongside their scoops.

Customer feedback echoes the quality and atmosphere here. While lines can be long, especially on holiday weekends with limited staff, the generosity of the portions and the affordable prices (with cones and cups around $3.75) make the wait worthwhile. The ice cream consistently earns praise for its creamy, non-gummy texture and vibrant flavors. Patrons appreciate the homemade, hand-scooped care that goes into each serving.

Overall, Ligonier Creamery stands as a must-visit stop for any ice cream enthusiast. Its combination of rich, thoughtfully crafted flavors, warm ambiance, and friendly service creates an experience that is both nostalgic and fresh. Whether you are strolling the Ligonier diamond or passing through town, this creamery invites you to savor ice cream the way it was meant to be—simple, delicious, and made with heart.